Discussion Apple Silicon SoC thread

Page 108 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

gdansk

Golden Member
Feb 8, 2011
1,209
1,182
136
What kind of workloads?
Exceedingly light after-work tasks. I think it's the default mail application. In total I had Chrome with maybe a dozen tabs, Mail, Preview and Finder open at the last time it forced me close applications. Confusingly, the Force Quit dialog didn't list any of the applications as using much memory. Just MacOS things™.

I actually never saw this dialog on my Intel MacBooks, even doing actual work. But hey this is really fast when it works.
 
Last edited:

igor_kavinski

Diamond Member
Jul 27, 2020
6,074
3,754
106
Exceedingly light after-work tasks. I think it's the default mail application. In total I had Chrome with maybe a dozen tabs, Mail, Preview and Finder open at the last time it forced me close applications. Confusingly, the Force Quit dialog didn't list any of the applications as using much memory. Just MacOS things™.

I actually never saw this dialog on my Intel MacBooks, even doing actual work. But hey this is really fast when it works.
Maybe a memory leak in some app. I'm guessing Chrome. You could check Activity Monitor at regular intervals to see if any app is unusuaaly consuming a lot of memory.
 

The Hardcard

Member
Oct 19, 2021
46
38
51
It wasn't Chrome. Mail app.
Are you using the standard pointer or a custom one?

This article claims to identify the causes of the memory leaks:


I haven’t had any big enough to affect my QoS or otherwise draw my attention and I’ve been using the Mail app.
 
Last edited:

gdansk

Golden Member
Feb 8, 2011
1,209
1,182
136
I don't customize much. Standard cursor, of course. I do use finder search quite often. Kinda annoying trying to figure out which daily feature is causing an annoying bug. Like a game of land mines. Monterey definitely was not ready for release.
 

igor_kavinski

Diamond Member
Jul 27, 2020
6,074
3,754
106
I don't customize much. Standard cursor, of course. I do use finder search quite often. Kinda annoying trying to figure out which daily feature is causing an annoying bug. Like a game of land mines. Monterey definitely was not ready for release.

Syrupy is a Python script that regularly takes snapshots of the memory and CPU load of one or more running processes, so as to dynamically build up a profile of their usage of system resources.
 

Mopetar

Diamond Member
Jan 31, 2011
6,922
4,223
136
I know this is anecdotal but my new M1 Pro MBP16 crashes due to out of memory more than my old 9750H MBP16. Both on Monterey, both 16GB. Maybe some memory leak in ARM versions?

But otherwise it seems generally faster and quieter. Work test suite completes a bit faster. And the battery life is much longer.
Exceedingly light after-work tasks. I think it's the default mail application. In total I had Chrome with maybe a dozen tabs, Mail, Preview and Finder open at the last time it forced me close applications. Confusingly, the Force Quit dialog didn't list any of the applications as using much memory. Just MacOS things™.

I actually never saw this dialog on my Intel MacBooks, even doing actual work. But hey this is really fast when it works.
I haven't had any issues like that, but maybe it's because I have more RAM. I also don't use the mail app either.

Maybe you could isolate it by just running that and nothing else to see if it happens. If it is a memory leak it should just be a matter of time.

Weird though since they've had their mail app native for a long time now and have been developing it for ARM for as long as they've had it on iOS. Maybe it's a bug in the latest version.
 

gdansk

Golden Member
Feb 8, 2011
1,209
1,182
136
It seems a lot of people on Reddit encounter it, seemingly regardless of application. Their advice is "restart more often" or watch Activity Monitor continually. Reminds me of the Windows 95 days again.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: lobz

Doug S

Golden Member
Feb 8, 2020
1,425
2,119
106
It seems a lot of people on Reddit encounter it, seemingly regardless of application. Their advice is "restart more often" or watch Activity Monitor continually. Reminds me of the Windows 95 days again.
New OS version has bugs. First time that's ever happened, bad Apple!

Oh wait, Windows 11 is pretty buggy too, for the same reason... Before long both will have patches to address the worst issues like this memory leak in macOS and the dog slow SSD in Windows 11.
 

gdansk

Golden Member
Feb 8, 2011
1,209
1,182
136
New OS version has bugs. First time that's ever happened, bad Apple!

Oh wait, Windows 11 is pretty buggy too, for the same reason... Before long both will have patches to address the worst issues like this memory leak in macOS and the dog slow SSD in Windows 11.
Well it shipped with this operating system. It's totally a dog crap out-of-the-box experience compared to any past Mac I've had. Even running the same nominal operating system (Monterey) my old MBP16 had never encountered these problems.

Not sure what Windows 11 has to do with it
 

DXDiag

Member
Nov 12, 2017
164
115
116
M1 Max wipes the floor with RTX 3080* in gaming.
This 3080 is maxing out at 80w, and it massively thermally limited.

Here is a good 3080 mobile with 165w and more thermal optimal conditions, the 3080 mobile is way faster.

 
Last edited:

igor_kavinski

Diamond Member
Jul 27, 2020
6,074
3,754
106
Progress Report: October-November 2021 - Asahi Linux

While working on AIC2 we discovered an interesting feature… while macOS only uses one set of IRQ control registers, there was indeed a full second set, unused and apparently unconnected to any hardware. Poking around, we found that it was indeed a fully working second half of the interrupt controller, and that interrupts delivered from it popped up with a magic “1” in a field of the event number, which had always been “0” previously. Yes, this is the much-rumored multi-die support. The M1 Max SoC has, by all appearances, been designed to support products with two of them in a multi-die module. While no such products exist yet, we’re introducing multi-die support to our AIC2 driver ahead of time. If we get lucky and there are no critical bugs, that should mean that Linux just works on those new 2-die machines, once they are released!
The physical address space size of the CPU cores increased from 36 bits (64 GiB) to 42 bits (4 TiB). The RAM region moved from the top 32 GiB of address space to the top 3 TiB. This means that while the old M1 chips were architecturally limited to a maximum of 32 GiB of RAM, the M1 Pro/Max revision can support up to at least 1 TiB or 3 TiB (depending on whether they want to keep it power-of-two aligned or not). Note that this is not how much memory the chips support in actuality, just how high the underlying architecture can scale without incompatible changes.
Apple engineers are likely thinking ahead to dominate the server world.
 
  • Like
Reactions: repoman27

StinkyPinky

Diamond Member
Jul 6, 2002
6,725
718
126
Yeah 165W is somewhat pushing it. Kinda stops being mobile at that point surely.

Technically gluing two EGPU's together with epoxy and sticking them in thunderbolt ports is also mobile.
 

Doug S

Golden Member
Feb 8, 2020
1,425
2,119
106
Progress Report: October-November 2021 - Asahi Linux

Apple engineers are likely thinking ahead to dominate the server world.

They need it for the Mac Pro. With LPDDR5X using 16Gb DRAMs allowing up to 64 GB per package, they could theoretically support 8 TB of LPDDR5X in a four SoC Mac Pro. I doubt they will offer anything that ridiculous, but I would expect they will offer at least 512 GB in the "smaller" two SoC Mac Pro due next year, and at least 2 TB if not more in the four SoC model in 2023.
 

jpiniero

Lifer
Oct 1, 2010
12,551
3,949
136
Yeah 165W is somewhat pushing it. Kinda stops being mobile at that point surely.
The 16" MBP with the M1 Max is pretty heavy. 4.8 pounds. The gamer laptops on NBC with the 3080 are mostly 5 or 6 pounds. Seems the battery might be the cause of it being so heavy.
 

Mopetar

Diamond Member
Jan 31, 2011
6,922
4,223
136
The 16" MBP with the M1 Max is pretty heavy. 4.8 pounds. The gamer laptops on NBC with the 3080 are mostly 5 or 6 pounds. Seems the battery might be the cause of it being so heavy.
The previous 16" MBP was 4.3 pounds so it's not that much more. I moved from an older 15" so the weigh difference is noticeable, but it's not noticeably worse to carry around.
 

guidryp

Platinum Member
Apr 3, 2006
2,649
3,492
136
even ram seem to be integrated into SOC !!! Also its LPDDR4x and not LPDDR5. But yearly updates like iphone. I guess we will see new macs every year like iphone.
Not integrated. Soldered onto the same package.

It's LPDDR4x for original M1, LPDDR5 for the Pro and Max.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Viknet

gdansk

Golden Member
Feb 8, 2011
1,209
1,182
136
even ram seem to be integrated into SOC !!! Also its LPDDR4x and not LPDDR5. But yearly updates like iphone. I guess we will see new macs every year like iphone.
I suspect a slower cadence for Macs. Yearly upgrade cycle isn't nearly as common as it is for phones. The M1 is already over a year old. When the M2 debuts it should be an indicator of what cadence Apple is planning for Macs.
 

scannall

Golden Member
Jan 1, 2012
1,902
1,531
136
I suspect a slower cadence for Macs. Yearly upgrade cycle isn't nearly as common as it is for phones. The M1 is already over a year old. When the M2 debuts it should be an indicator of what cadence Apple is planning for Macs.
Apple has already said the M series is on an 18 month cadence.
 

ASK THE COMMUNITY