Originally posted by: jeffrey
I'm thinking of 3 nights Athens then 3 on Mykonos or another island and then back for a night in Athens before flying home.
Which Greek island do you spend most of your time at?
FYI, Mykonos is a haven for gay tourists. That's fine, just letting you know it has that reputation.
I vacation on the island next door: Naxos (see sig for pics). It offers a nice blend of sandy, family-friendly beaches and good nightlife.
Santorini is the photographer's paradise but lacks in nightlife.
If you want extreme peace and quiet, then I suggest some of the smaller islands like Syros, Sifnos, Donoussa, and Antiparos.
You could also head west from Athens instead of south to the Cyclades (mentioned above). Going west, you could explore more of mainland Greece, then head off to Corfu (home of the infamous Pink Palace), Kefalonia, and Zakynthos. These (Ionian) islands arguably offer more of a southern Italian feel.
If you start to plan seriously, I can provide all sorts of other recommendations.