Originally posted by: edprush
Originally posted by: Dominionion
We went some years ago on the Mandalay. I higher recomend the Mandaley over the other boats as its a bit smaller and personable. The cabin was very nice, we paid a little for a nicer/larger cabin on the main deck( I'd recommend getting the most cabin you can aford ). The Mandalay had maybe 60 passengers and we went places the larger cruise ships didn't go and with only 60 people, when we hit an island it wasn't like a cruise ship invasion with a 1000+ storming the beach! Also, with the Mandalay you'll get more of a 'sailing' feel then say the larger Polynesia. The Madalay has some structure to the cruise( we'll be at this island tomorrow and the next day we'll stop at... etc. etc.), but far less than the big cruise ships.
The next time we went back we chartered our own 50ft sailboat with captain and cook. That was total freedom. We went where we wanted, when we wanted... the only rule was we had to be at the plane on a certain date ;-) The private boat wasn't that more expensive.
Anyway, have fun!
WOW, a chartered sailboat huh? So this was an overnight trip too? Do you know a link to the site from which you chartered the trip?
That sounds incredible. I would have assumed it would cost at least 4x more than just regular Windjammer cruise.
I did some checking, the gap in pricing has gotten much greater since we went. We went on the Mandalay for two weeks at ( I think ) 1K each(2K total). The next time was a crewed 50ft sail boat for two weeks at 4K total. Prices look higher now, but you can always save going in the offseason(we did). And the price difference is worth it, the captain and cook only care about two people, you and your wife/GF. We'd find a place we liked and tell the captain we wanted to stay here a couple of days, and we did. We set the menus. We were King and Queen =-)
But the Mandalay was lots of fun too, but it was us and 60 other people( still way better than 1000+ shipmates )...
So my ten cents would be... If you can't afford a crewed charter, go Windjammer. Check out the pictures on their site, you can kind of get a feel for which ships are true Sailing ships and which are heavier Sail/Powered ships( assuming you are after the sailing experience ). The Mandalay is a true Sailer and more intimate. But you'll have fun no matter what you choose!
Here's a site for charters. The site we used is no longer around, but this one was started by one of the founders. Theres lots of other sites too. But look at some of the boats and pictures. The difference between a crewed charter and a Windjammer is like the difference between a Windjammer and one of the big cruise ships.
Crewed Charters