If I had to rank the concertos (for each individual instruments):
Violin:
1 Beethoven
2 Mendelssohn
3 Brahms
4 Sibelius
5 Tchaikovsky
Honerable Mentions: Saint-Saens, Paganini, Glazumov, Brusch, Mozart, Prokofiev
Piano:
1 Rachmaninoff No. 3
2 Rachmaninoff No. 2
2 Tchaikovsky No. 1
4 Brahms No. 2
5 Beethoven No.5 "emperor"
6 Mozart No. 21
Honerable Mentions: Mozart (many of his 27 Piano Concertos), Liszt, Chopin, Saint-Saens
Cello:
1 Dvorak
2 Elgar
3 Haydn
I change my mind between Dvorak and Elgar all the time... they are definitely the two best cello concertos. The Elgar is very sombre, even depressing at times.
Violin:
1 Beethoven
2 Mendelssohn
3 Brahms
4 Sibelius
5 Tchaikovsky
Honerable Mentions: Saint-Saens, Paganini, Glazumov, Brusch, Mozart, Prokofiev
Piano:
1 Rachmaninoff No. 3
2 Rachmaninoff No. 2
2 Tchaikovsky No. 1
4 Brahms No. 2
5 Beethoven No.5 "emperor"
6 Mozart No. 21
Honerable Mentions: Mozart (many of his 27 Piano Concertos), Liszt, Chopin, Saint-Saens
Cello:
1 Dvorak
2 Elgar
3 Haydn
I change my mind between Dvorak and Elgar all the time... they are definitely the two best cello concertos. The Elgar is very sombre, even depressing at times.
