I had an 09 Fit Sport. It is one awesome car in term of utility. I can tell you of all the cars you've looked at, it none of them can carry as much stuff as the honda fit.
The cargo room in this car is incredible. It came in handy numerous times when I have to haul stuff. My GF loved the car as well because she took it on a road trip with her friend and amazed at the cargo room the car have to haul their stuff.
I get about 32 mpg with it and that's pretty good, None of the SUV could come close to the FIT in term of mileage + cargo room. It's either get an suv with terrible gas mileage and get great cargo room or get a SUV with OK gas mileage and get OK cargo room. The fit does both.
The car is very cheap to maintain and ride.
The only thing I don't like about the car is the Weak A/C, the interior is too large for such a small A/C unit and it doesn't cool the car down enough to my liking. Also the car is pretty slow & was an automatic 🙁
Those reasons alone caused me to get rid of it and bought a 2011 Honda Civic Si which I am extremely satisfied with. Other than refueling it with Premium gasoline, there's nothing I hate about this Civic.
I do miss not having the honda fit though cause of the cargo room.