<<But do you really see it as important for someone who's going to be a tradesman take years upon years of lit classes? How about a system where the general education ends at around 9th grade, and after that you can choose to go on to a university prep school, or go to trade school. I believe they do that in Europe, I know Germany is something like that anyway. Then rather than waste time and money on schooling for people that have no interest in being there, that money can be used to pay for their trade schooling. That has the added bonus of those people not having to pay for their own trade schooling, and they won't start life with college loans over their heads.>>
You make a good point, and I do like the German school system (I took 5 years of German in HS, and I'm relatively familiar with the general setup of the system). The flaw I see in such a system, however, is what happens when a 30 year old tradesman decides he wants to go to University because he is dis-satisfied with his job. Because he lacks the general education background of the students who went to a college prep school, he will have a very hard time with this. Also, how many people know what they want to do when they are in the 9th grade? I'll be a Sophomore in college next year and I'm still not entirely certain of what it is that I want to do, how can we expect a 14-15 year old to know what they want to do with their life? And if the student canot make the decision, who does? His parents? The school board? Is it right for such an important decision to be out of the hands of the person whom it most affects? The decision of what to do with one's life is made all the more complicated if that person has not been exposed to a wide variety of subjects, which is the function of HS. By exposing teens to a large variety of possible subject areas, HS permits people to make more educated choices about what they want to do with their lives, and in doing so it prepares them for the specificity that is inherent in college. As for the tradesman taking years of literature classes, my personal opinion is that it is quite important. Literature is a window to ideas and places different from our own, and without exposure to different ideas, the mind never expands. One of my good friends from my Honors and AP English Literature classes is currently going to a trade school because he plans on taking over his father's Heating and Air Conditioning business. He may not be the first to pick up a copy of Candide, but he still reads a lot and in doing so he is able to keep himself abreast of current happenings. I just don't think there is much weight to the argument that a tradesman doesn't need Literature classes. The more a person knows, the farther they will be able to go in life.