Andre Johnson for Roy Williams

[Doboji]

I have Johnson....

 

[Albis]

i think williams will earn his keep as the year gets going. i'm a lions fan so i am bias

 

[SVT Cobra]

sure why not

but I hate you

 

[Yreka]

Originally posted by: Albis
i think williams will earn his keep as the year gets going. i'm a lions fan so i am bias

X2 including the bias

 

[spanky]

i think i would keep johnson.

 

[TheNinja]

I have no bias towards either team, but I think Williams is the better player. I'd take Williams if you are willing to live with the injury risk

edit: sorry, got the injury thing mixed up with Charles Rogers. I'd go with williams

 

[CtK]

if u think Joey Harrington can get him the ball go ahead and trade
but i would wait and see how Houston plays when they come back next week with the new Offensive Coordinator

 

[geecee]

Interesting. Andre has some nice matchups against weak defenses in the coming weeks. But he has no complementary receiver and his QB (due to a weak O-line) is not getting enough time to get the ball to him (or would be unable to regardless, depending on who you ask). The offense (in general) is weak (with the exception of DD, who might also be suffering from the lousy O-line), which may not give him many opportunities to make big plays. Roy Williams, OTOH, has a generally decent offense (other good receivers in Rogers, KJohnson & MWilliams, good RB in KJones) with a lousy QB (Harrington). Unfortunately, the QB who might make the difference (Garcia) probably won't be available until mid-season. So for a while, you can only hope that Harrington gets better in a hurry. I already dealt AJ in one of my leagues and thus am biased in saying that you should probably go get Williams.

 

[imported_Ed]

I do it most likely, if Johnson was a 3rd or 4th option for you.