And THIS is why US cellular providers suck.

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

lothar

Diamond Member
Jan 5, 2000
6,674
7
76
Better than US prepaid, they include zero roaming.
That is absolutely false.
Straight Talk does have voice roaming, and you're not limited to 60 minutes either.

US prepaid doesn't offer coverage in only one city like this plan does.
Once you leave Toronto, you can only roam for 60 minutes.
With US prepaid, you will have service in DC, Houston, Sacramento, New York, Atlanta, Los Angeles...

Would you rather have service in only one city and once you leave that 20 square mile city radius, you'll only have 60 minutes to roam regardless of where you are in the entire United States?
 

lothar

Diamond Member
Jan 5, 2000
6,674
7
76
Looks like moblicity has native coverage in several MAJOR canadian cities according to their coverage map. Not "one" as everybody likes to claim.
http://mobilicity.ca/coverage-map/

It would help you to check out their coverage map. They have native coverage in about 4-5 cities...Of those only Toronto (and maybe Vancouver) is worth mentioning since it's very much bigger than the others.
Zoom in closely on those maps.

Pink: Unlimited zone
Purple: Roaming zone.
Yellow: Future expansion(meaning they haven't expanded there yet and you will therefore roam there).
Blank: No service.

You can only spend a total of 60 minutes total in those purple and yellow zones?
Good lord...

I'm sure if AT&T or Verizon did something similar like this with only 5 major US cities getting coverage and everywhere else is limited to 60 minutes roaming, people here will be up in arms.
This company is only able to get by because it's a Canadian company and not an American telecom carrier.
 

Madwand1

Diamond Member
Jan 23, 2006
3,309
0
76
Would you rather have service in only one city and once you leave that 20 square mile city radius, you'll only have 60 minutes to roam regardless of where you are in the entire United States?

Mobilicity's roaming rates are pretty reasonable in comparison to the competitors. Their coverage is the bigger problem, and not a big problem if like many Canadians, you live in a big city and don't regularly leave it (of course it's a big country and many people live differently, and Quebec is a specific exception because another carrier bought out all the spectrum there).

Straight Talk also has limitations. E.g. trying to roam in Canada can get your service terminated. Its GSM roaming in US is a good deal though, no doubt due to how they're licensed through other carriers.

International Roaming is strictly prohibited. Straight Talk does not offer international roaming or international long distance service. You will not be able to make or receive calls on your Straight Talk phone if you are traveling outside of the United States. Any attempt to place or receive a call on your Straight Talk phone while traveling outside of the United States could result is service deactivation and account termination without a refund for unused service.

Full coverage is very expensive to set up in a country as big and sparsely populated as Canada, and the model Mobilicity and others have set up -- targeting the biggest metropolitan areas only -- is probably one that the big carriers wish they could get away with, as they have tried to in part, by setting up special plans and even subsidiary carrier brands with limitation to major metropolitan areas.

The Canadian wireless regulator auctioned some new spectrum in a way to encourage new carriers to get into the market and to bring the bigger ones some (any) competition. This has worked well from the point of view of the consumers, who have gotten more choice and some price drops from the large carriers.
 

lothar

Diamond Member
Jan 5, 2000
6,674
7
76
Mobilicity's roaming rates are pretty reasonable in comparison to the competitors. Their coverage is the bigger problem, and not a big problem if like many Canadians, you live in a big city and don't regularly leave it (of course it's a big country and many people live differently, and Quebec is a specific exception because another carrier bought out all the spectrum there).

Straight Talk also has limitations. E.g. trying to roam in Canada can get your service terminated. Its GSM roaming in US is a good deal though, no doubt due to how they're licensed through other carriers.



Full coverage is very expensive to set up in a country as big and sparsely populated as Canada, and the model Mobilicity and others have set up -- targeting the biggest metropolitan areas only -- is probably one that the big carriers wish they could get away with, as they have tried to in part, by setting up special plans and even subsidiary carrier brands with limitation to major metropolitan areas.

The Canadian wireless regulator auctioned some new spectrum in a way to encourage new carriers to get into the market and to bring the bigger ones some (any) competition. This has worked well from the point of view of the consumers, who have gotten more choice and some price drops from the large carriers.
http://mobilicity.ca/coverage-map/
Mobilicity doesn't support international roaming based on the coverage map shown on their website either.
 

Madwand1

Diamond Member
Jan 23, 2006
3,309
0
76
http://mobilicity.ca/coverage-map/
Mobilicity doesn't support international roaming based on the coverage map shown on their website either.

That coverage map is only for Canada. Beyond that, the roaming most people would care about is the US, which is at the same price as in Canada. They also do GSM roaming in many other countries, though at higher cost.

To be honest though, for more than very limited usage, I'd probably get a local SIM and use that instead of roaming. Their phones are directly compatible with T-Mobile US, and can do GSM elsewhere.
 

kaerflog

Golden Member
Jul 23, 2010
1,899
4
76
Well back to the point of the OP.
Trying to show that US cellular providers suck because of some prepaid plan in Canada that cost $30 is a major fail.
There are plenty of prepaid here in the US that are just as cheap with better coverage.
 

lothar

Diamond Member
Jan 5, 2000
6,674
7
76
Trying to show that US cellular providers suck because of some prepaid plan in Canada that cost $30 is a major fail.
There are plenty of prepaid here in the US that are just as cheap(if not cheaper) with much better coverage.
Fixed.
 

lothar

Diamond Member
Jan 5, 2000
6,674
7
76
My bad. Didn't know they allowed roaming.
It's mostly the Sprint MVNOs that don't have roaming.
That said, Sprint MVNO "native" coverage is still probably miles better than what Mobilicity's coverage offers with roaming taken into account.
 

Mwing

Senior member
Sep 29, 2001
294
0
76
cheapest plan i have seen is in hk, where china mobile offers 3800 min voice in hk, unlimited 4g lte in hk and china, for $138 hkd, which is $17.77 usd per month, dense population provides cheaper cellphone plan i guess