american remakes of foriegn movies?

[thomsbrain]

i used to be in the "all remakes are bad" camp, but it seems like hollywood has been doing ok with some remakes in the last few years, notably vanilla sky, solaris, and insomnia. all of those movies were equally as good as their foriegn counterparts, IMO.

what you say? (move all zig) remakes, yay or nay?

 

[alexeikgb]

:thumbsdown:

 

[Anonemous]

Originally posted by: alexeikgb
:thumbsdown:

edit: but they provide a good way for the older movies to be reviewed by the younger generation to compare.

 

[Martin]

in general, no. Taxi looks pretty f-ing horrible.

 

[Forsythe]

Holy fvcking christ no!

 

[Howard]

I'm quite curious about how they're going to work Infernal Affairs.

 

[Forsythe]

Originally posted by: thomsbrain
i used to be in the "all remakes are bad" camp, but it seems like hollywood has been doing ok with some remakes in the last few years, notably vanilla sky, solaris, and insomnia. all of those movies were equally as good as their foriegn counterparts, IMO.

what you say? (move all zig) remakes, yay or nay?

I agree with you on those three movies. They were good, but no match for their counterparts imo. I'd rather live without those 3 than have all of those crappy remakes!

 

[Passions]

Hollywood is going to remake alot of Korean movies:

Yupki Jukin Guh Nyuh
Jopok Manura


etc.

 

[imported_Kensai]

Only the originals are good.
So;
BOO!!

 

[biostud]

Nay

 

[Anonemous]

Originally posted by: Passions
Hollywood is going to remake alot of Korean movies:

Yupki Jukin Guh Nyuh
Jopok Manura


etc.

what are those (translated)?

 

[bandana163]

I am yet to see a good Hollywood-style remake of a great foreign classic.

 

[Maximus96]

Originally posted by: Howard
I'm quite curious about how they're going to work Infernal Affairs.

me too.

 

[machintos]

I think it's okay to remake films.
True, the original is better, but without the american version, I never would've known about vanilla sky, ring, or the grudge and never would've thought about watching any of these movies.

 

[dbzwukan]

Originally posted by: machintos
I think it's okay to remake films.
True, the original is better, but without the american version, I never would've known about vanilla sky, ring, or the grudge and never would've thought about watching any of these movies.

seems like japanese people can make good horror flicks.

 

[Attrox]

Originally posted by: zaku

Originally posted by: Howard
I'm quite curious about how they're going to work Infernal Affairs.

me too.

bah they probably gonna change the ending and put a stupid actor to play like Ben Aflack

 

[Attrox]

Originally posted by: dbzwukan

Originally posted by: machintos
I think it's okay to remake films.
True, the original is better, but without the american version, I never would've known about vanilla sky, ring, or the grudge and never would've thought about watching any of these movies.

seems like japanese people can make good horror flicks.

Yup.. the original ring and ju on(the grudge) are scarier.

 

[neilm]

NAY. Be original and make something new... especially these cartoon ones that have recently been released, scooby doo, garfield... they are ruinin our childhood idols with the crap they are makin now.

 

[Quasmo]

we need a remake of Battle Royale!!!

 

[Attrox]

Originally posted by: Quasmo
we need a remake of Battle Royale!!!

Haha.. what will the movie rating be? I don't think the movie will even pass the censorship

 

[z0mb13]

vanilla sky is based of a foreign movie?

 

[eplebnista]

nay

 

[Mo0o]

Usually not. does anyone have a counter example?

 

[mugs]

Depends on the movie, and how well-done the remake is. Being foreign doesn't make a movie good, being good makes a movie good.

 

[Attrox]

Originally posted by: mugs
Depends on the movie, and how well-done the remake is. Being foreign doesn't make a movie good, being good makes a movie good.

Being remake by Hollywood makes the movie less good