That video is an intellectually-vacuous hit job, if you ask me. Ben Shapiro identifies as an Orthodox Jew and is on record as proposing (approx. 10 years ago) that all Palestinians be expelled from the West Bank. So his view in this debate is well-known. He's fully entitled to his beliefs of course, but what we should NOT accept are his logic fails.
From the video:
Now the question isn't whether Islam itself is violent, it's what its adherents believe, because that's what they act upon.
This premise, from which he launches his entire diatribe, is utter nonsense. Just like Christianity, Islam has its own holy book, and the Koran has its own very clear version of "
thou shalt not kill." You can only validly claim to be a Muslim if you observe this basic rule. If you kill, no matter what twisted interpretation of the Koran you use, you are not a Muslim
Just like Christianiy, Buddhism, Hinduism and any other major religion, Islam is a religion of peace. The vast majority of the world's Muslims are as peaceful as you or I. The fact that some extremist assholes commit violence and claim to be Muslims does
NOT mean they are Muslims. Just like anyone claiming to kill in the name of Christianity is not a Christian.
What someone believes and what actions they take are important, granted, but we should always judge the
person for this and
not the religion/nation/team that they claim to represent...unless of course that religion/nation/team clearly supports these actions.
An even bigger logic fail:
There are approximately 1.6 Muslims on the planet...Indonesia the the most populous Muslim country; it's got almost 205 million Muslims living there. According to one 2009 poll it showed that...70% [of Indonesians] blame Israel, the United States or someone else for 9/11. So, you make that calculation and it's about 143 million people who are radicalized. Are you scared yet? Well we're just getting started
Wow, wow, the stupid in this is staggering. So if you answer 'yes' to the question "
Do you believe that Israel, the US or 'someone else' was behind 9/11?" then you are radicalized. FFS! Nearly all of us believe 'someone' was responsible for 9/11. The only way you could answer 'no' to that question would be if you thought the whole thing was some massive 'coincidence' or an act of God.
But he takes this as a metric of being radicalized, and uses it to say that 143 million Indonesians (70% of 205 million) are therefore radicalized. If I pulled this in a First Year social sciences essay back in my uni days, the fact that I used a single poll would itself be grounds for very low marks. Defining 'being radicalized' as believing that 'someone' was behind 9/11 would have resulted in an instant fail and moreover would have had the lecturer wonder how it is I got into the course in the first place.
Seriously, as a refutation this video is a POS.