AL-JAZEERA: Cameraman Killed when US bomb hit building that housed al-jazeera reporters

dahunan

Lifer
Jan 10, 2002
18,191
3
0
AL-JAZEERA: CAMERAMAN KILLED
Building Housing Al-Jazeera Hit

Apr. 8 ? Al-Jazeera said one of its cameramen was killed on Tuesday in a U.S. air raid on Baghdad which set ablaze the network's downtown office.
Video without translaton.
 

Phuz

Diamond Member
Jul 15, 2000
4,349
0
0
Originally posted by: MooseKnuckle
It's too bad, but it would be nice to see their propaganda machine shutdown.

Heh, too bad FOX is just as bad as they are.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Al Jeezeara's OWN report
Al Jazeera correspondent killed in US attack


Al-Jazeera correspondent Tariq Ayoub was killed on Tuesday when two US missiles struck the Baghdad offices of the Qatar-based channel.




Two more journalists died and four others were injured when a US tank round later hit the Palestine Hotel where at least 200 international correspondents, including Al-Jazeera reporters, are staying.


"We regret to inform you that our cameraman and correspondent Tariq Ayoub was killed this morning during the US missile strike on our Baghdad office," the Qatar-based channel said in a statement read out during its news bulletin.



Another cameraman, Zuheir Iraqi, was slightly wounded with shrapnel to his neck.
Ayoub giving his last report minutes before the US attack



They were both standing on the roof getting ready for a live broadcast amid intensifying bombardment of the city when the building was hit by two missiles, according to Tayseer Allouni, another Al Jazeera correspondent.



Cameraman Iraqi came down bleeding, but Ayoub did not show up. ?I ran up as the shells were still falling and crawled on the roof and shouted for Tariq, but he did not answer,? Allouni said.



Allouni had gone down because of the intense bombing. He later went up again and with the help of Abu Dhabi TV correspondent, Jaber Obeid, they found Ayoub?s body.



Allouni, Jaber and others held Ayoub?s body which was covered by a blanket and placed it in Abu Dhabi TV?s vehicle that transported it to hospital.



Shortly afterwards, US warplanes returned to hit the neighbouring Abu Dhabi TV offices.



?It seems that we have become a target,? said Allouni.



Another of Jazeera's Baghdad correspondents Majed Abdel Hadi called the U.S. missile strike and Ayoub's death a "crime".



"I will not be objective about this because we have been dragged into this conflict," he said, visibly upset. "We were targeted because the Americans don't want the world to see the crimes they are committing against the Iraqi people."



Al-Jazeera aired footage of Ayoub only one hour before his death as he was preparing to go live. He was leaning on sandbags and wearing a helmet and a flack jacket.



?I knew Tariq for 10 years ,? said Yasser Abu Hilalah, Al-Jazeera correspondent in Amman. ?He was very brave, professional and a hard worker,? he added. ?Al-Jazeera office is located in a residential area and there is no way that the attack was a mistake.?


Ayoub. aged 35, was married with one daughter. He travelled to Baghdad only five days ago to join the Al-Jazeera team from the channel's Amman office where he had worked as a financial correspondent for three years. Originally from Palestine, he had also worked for the Jordan Times and the international news agency Associated Press.

Earlier, Abdel-Hadi told our presenter that Al-Jazeera office was ?deliberately targeted? and it is not the first time. Our Kabul office was hit by four (US) missiles,? he said. US warplanes hit the Afghanistan office of Al Jazeera in 2001, just 10 minutes after its correspondents had received warning of an impending attack.



Last week, the hotel where Al-Jazeera correspondents in the southern Iraqi city of Basra was also hit by four bombs that did not explode.



?Al-Jazeera team has no role in the war. We are only witnesses and are reporting objectively. This proves that the US is trying to cover the crime its commits in its war on Iraq. Targeting witnesses is the biggest crime,? said Abdel-Hadi, visibly upset.



Today's bombing left Al Jazeera's offices a ruin. But the channel said it would continue its coverage of the US-led war on Iraq that began on March 20. ?It is impossible to work in the office, but we will continue to cover the war within the capabilities that we have and despite the difficult circumstances,? Abdel-Hadi said.



The European Union said after the incident it is to call on the United States to keep journalists out of the firing line.



Greek Foreign Minister George Papandreou and EU foreign policy chief Javier Solana had "agreed to make a joint representation to the United States in order to protect journalists," he said. "Greece condemns this repugnant act and expresses its sorrow and regret."




Reporters carry a wounded cameraman from Spanish channel Telecinco from the Palestine Hotel after it was hit by a shell 08 April, leaving one reporter dead and many injured. AFP PHOTO/Karim SAHIB

A Reuters journalist, Taras Protsyuk, 35, a Ukrainian national, who who was married with an eight-year-old son, died today after his hotel was struck by a US tank round.



"Taras's death, and the injuries sustained by the others, were so unnecessary," said Reuters' editor in chief Geert Linnebank.



He called into question the "judgement of advancing US troops who have known all along that this hotel is the main base for almost all foreign journalists in Baghdad."



Reuters has its offices on the 15th floor of the Palestine Hotel which houses most of the foreign media covering the Iraq war.



The 15th and 17th floors of the hotel were struck, blowing out windows as fierce exchanges raged on the 20th day of the US-led war.



The 14th floor was also damaged. A hole had been knocked in the hotel facade, laying bare the metal structure of a column running past a balcony.



Dubai's Al-Arabiya television channel said its bureau on the 17th floor also suffered damage.



General Buford Blount, commander of the US 3rd Infantry Division said a US tank was "receiving fire from the hotel, RPG (rocket-propelled grenade) and small-arms fire, and engaged with one tank round. The firing stopped."



But BBC correspondent Rageh Omar cast doubt on the US line saying he heard no gunfire from the hotel prior to it being hit. --- Al Jazeera and agencies
From the "horse's mouth". ;)

 

Mrpilot007

Senior member
Jan 5, 2003
227
0
76
I do feel bad that they died but they can't be mad at us. We are getting fired upon from that building that they happen to be in. When you're running around a war zone as a neutral element I'd say your chances of getting killed are at least 50% if not greater.
 

Stark

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2000
7,735
0
0
Since when was there a rule that someone could go into a warzone, carry a camera around and not worry about being hurt?

If you want to be a hero war correspondent, you have to accept the risks that go along with it. There's a reason Brian Williams and Wolf Blitzer are still in Kuwait city.
 

anazoal

Senior member
May 30, 2000
421
0
0
If you have a camera on a roof top in a residential neighbourhood with the words "Al Jazeera TV" painted next to you on the roof, you don't expect to be hit with a missile. ...With hindsight, they should have painted "CNN" on the roof.
 
Mar 21, 2000
67
0
0
Brigadier General Vincent Brooks is my hero.

How he managed to field a dozen questions repeatly about this topic this morning and not blow his top is AMAZING. He did this being polite all the way watching his Ps & Qs.

Watching those reporters phrase the same question over and over is a talent I will never quite understand as well. Either they are smart or just idiots I can't really tell.
 

exp

Platinum Member
May 9, 2001
2,150
0
0
I feel very bad for those who died and the families they leave behind, but that does comes with the territory of being a war correspondent. :(

 

Marshallj

Platinum Member
Mar 26, 2003
2,326
0
76
Originally posted by: anazoal
If you have a camera on a roof top in a residential neighbourhood with the words "Al Jazeera TV" painted next to you on the roof, you don't expect to be hit with a missile. ...With hindsight, they should have painted "CNN" on the roof.

We also don't expect to be shot at from a building that says "Al Jazeera TV"

Why were gunmen using a TV station building? Didn't Al Jazeera TV know about this? Or did their anti-American views enable them to turn a blind eye to that fact?

 

da loser

Platinum Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,037
0
0
I bet what happened was people with cameras were capturing the video, and perhaps even taking photographs with flash photography which could be mistaken for gun shots. Not sure what kind of optics are on the tanks and the degree of fidelity, though. Anyway i think its possible in the confusion to mistake journalists for snipers. Of course there may also have been snipers. Either way there was obviously something in those buildings. perhaps they need to set their cameras and run :)
 

yowolabi

Diamond Member
Jun 29, 2001
4,183
2
81
Originally posted by: Mrpilot007
I do feel bad that they died but they can't be mad at us. We are getting fired upon from that building that they happen to be in. When you're running around a war zone as a neutral element I'd say your chances of getting killed are at least 50% if not greater.

Where do you get this information that there was firing from that building? I haven't even seen the US military claim that.
 

Marshallj

Platinum Member
Mar 26, 2003
2,326
0
76
Originally posted by: da loser
I bet what happened was people with cameras were capturing the video, and perhaps even taking photographs with flash photography which could be mistaken for gun shots. Not sure what kind of optics are on the tanks and the degree of fidelity, though. Anyway i think its possible in the confusion to mistake journalists for snipers. Of course there may also have been snipers. Either way there was obviously something in those buildings. perhaps they need to set their cameras and run :)

They wouldn't use a flash at those distances. Flash is for taking pictures of something up close.

 

HappyGamer2

Banned
Jun 12, 2000
1,441
0
0
if we listened to Fox and MSNBC, we would believe that Iraq has enough WMD to kill the whole earth 5 times over again
 

Tiger

Platinum Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,312
0
0
Where do you get this information that there was firing from that building? I haven't even seen the US military claim that.
It was all over the news. The tank crew came under fire from a sniper in that building. The tank crew returned fire.
 

etech

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
10,597
0
0
Originally posted by: HappyGamer2
if we listened to Fox and MSNBC, we would believe that Iraq has enough WMD to kill the whole earth 5 times over again

Prove it. Link to a story on either of those two sites that says that.

I'm tired of the rhetoric that gets spewed by some. The lies and misinformation some are spreading are what is going to cause more deaths in the future.
 

anazoal

Senior member
May 30, 2000
421
0
0
Originally posted by: Marshallj
Originally posted by: anazoal
If you have a camera on a roof top in a residential neighbourhood with the words "Al Jazeera TV" painted next to you on the roof, you don't expect to be hit with a missile. ...With hindsight, they should have painted "CNN" on the roof.

We also don't expect to be shot at from a building that says "Al Jazeera TV"

Why were gunmen using a TV station building? Didn't Al Jazeera TV know about this? Or did their anti-American views enable them to turn a blind eye to that fact?


If you are referring to the "casings" theory from the Al-Jazeera offices, the theory was refuted within 10 mins of the report (~2:30 AM EST) by Fox News (the people who started it) when slow motion clearly showed that the "casings" were in fact concrete shards kicked up by incoming bullets.

Maybe you are confusing the Al-Jazeera incident with the Palestine hotel incident where a US tank shot at the hotel, claiming shots were fired from the hotel housing Western journalists. I'm sure you still harbor the same feelings knowing that Spanish journalists working for Reuters were killed in that incident. The journalists in the Palestine hotel stated there was no provocation from anyone for the attack by the US tank. Read the BBC or ITV News reports.

 

anazoal

Senior member
May 30, 2000
421
0
0
BTW, the best theory I have heard for these two incidents is that the equipment used to find snipers is mistakenly aiming at cameras or binoculars used by journalists.

Anyway, these incidents prove that accidents do happen in war, so why is everyone incensed when Al-Jazeera shows the destruction in Baghdad or dead/injured civilians? Why are we so afraid to see the horrors of war? If we feel that the war was justified, we would have no qualms about the "collateral damage".
 

Marshallj

Platinum Member
Mar 26, 2003
2,326
0
76
I don't have any more info on this than anyone else watching the news does.

The news said we shot at the hotel after we come under fire from it. I doubt that we'd shoot at a civilian target if we didn't have a pretty good idea that there was a threat there.
 

Alistar7

Lifer
May 13, 2002
11,978
0
0
There were western media in the building as well, so I doubt the claims of the Arab media that this was directed at them. I also think the idea this was done to "silence" the media is a joke, why then would the pentagon embed 500+ reporters giving them access to front line information?

 

Alistar7

Lifer
May 13, 2002
11,978
0
0
Originally posted by: yowolabi
Originally posted by: Mrpilot007
I do feel bad that they died but they can't be mad at us. We are getting fired upon from that building that they happen to be in. When you're running around a war zone as a neutral element I'd say your chances of getting killed are at least 50% if not greater.

Where do you get this information that there was firing from that building? I haven't even seen the US military claim that.

I wathced part of a clip and it appeared there was fire coming from the builind, not mortar being kicked up, but small arms and possibly machine gun fire barrel flashes. Would anyone be suprised if Saddam's men used the reporters and their buildings as a shield....
 

anazoal

Senior member
May 30, 2000
421
0
0
The news said we shot at the hotel after we come under fire from it. I doubt that we'd shoot at a civilian target if we didn't have a pretty good idea that there was a threat there.
This is war and sometimes troops have to make split-second decisions -- accidents do happen. My point is that civilians are suffering and we are angry because Al-Jazeera shows the suffering of war.