Adkins diet - anyone done it?

Cadaver

Senior member
Feb 19, 2002
344
0
0
Has anyone here ever been on the Adkins diet? What are your opinions?

I aiming to loose about 20 pounds. I don't need to do it fast, but something that will last. And yes, I'm on an excercise program, too.
 

TourGuide

Golden Member
Aug 19, 2000
1,680
0
76
My sister in law and her husband did that diet and yes it does work. There are restrictions though so research first.
 

AlienCraft

Lifer
Nov 23, 2002
10,539
0
0
Originally posted by: Cadaver
Has anyone here ever been on the Adkins diet? What are your opinions?

I aiming to loose about 20 pounds. I don't need to do it fast, but something that will last. And yes, I'm on an excercise program, too.
It's ATKINS.
Some day, not paying attention to English pronunciation and spelling WILL bite one in the ass.

 

Rob9874

Diamond Member
Nov 7, 1999
3,314
1
81
Personally, I don't like Atkins. From the research I've done, and the people I know who have done it, your body's shock to the diet results is a quick weight loss, but most gain it back. I think any time you alter your diet in such a manner, it's not healthy. IT's good for a quick weight loss, but not long term. Are you going to eat like that the rest of your life? If not, what do you htink will happen when you eat carbs again and put down the butter, cheese, and bacon?

Personally, I've had great success with Weight Watchers, and know many people who have also. Unlike a diet, it doesn't restrict what you eat, just how much you eat of it. You get a certain number of points for the day, based on calories, fiber, and fat content. The amount of points you get is determined by your weight. If you eat within your points, you will almost certainly lose weight. And the great thing is, you don't have to eat certain foods or eliminate others. It's not a diet, but a permanent change in eating habits.

For example, say you get 30 points for the day. Most vegetables are 0 points. So you can eat them all day. A slice of pizza is usually 6 points. So you can eat pizza, but if you eat 5 slices, you need to eat salad the rest of the day. You learn what to eat and what you want to stay away from. My thing was soda. Each can of soda has about 3 points. I could drink 5 a day, easily. I quickly realized that I didn't want to spend half of my daily points on beverages, so now I drink diet or water. Without the program, I wouldn't know how to compensate for the calories.

I've been on since May 5th (8 weeks), and have taken off 18 pounds. My goal is 2 pounds a week, and I'm right on target. Any faster of a weight loss, and I'm afraid it won't stay off. Slow and steady is my pace, and it'll stay off for good.
 

SWScorch

Diamond Member
May 13, 2001
9,520
1
76
Why are people so afraid to go out and run a few miles, but they'll starve themselves to death on some weird diet just to lose a few pounds? These diets never work in the long-term because you're robbing your body of its fuel. Just go out and get some exercise, don't eat Taco Bell every day and you'll shed the pounds in a little while and feel great.

I know you said you're in an exercise plan; good for you. I'm not specifically targeting you with my post; it just reminded me of all these people who do stuff like this. Seriously, you dont need to go on any diet except one: stay away from fast food and soda, eat home-cooked meals, and run a few times a week and you'll be fine.
 

TwinkleToes77

Diamond Member
Jul 13, 2002
5,086
1
0
atkins isnt a diet.. its a change of habit.. It cuts your carbs down to a very low level for 2 weeks and then you slowly increase them each week until you reach your limit your body can handle before turning back into fat and gaining weight. I've done the atkins thing but im a slave to carbs and i couldnt last more than 1 week on it. GOTTA HAVE MY BREAD.
 

bcterps

Platinum Member
Aug 31, 2000
2,795
0
76
If you're willing to make the lifestyle change, than it'll work, otherwise, it's like any other fad diet, you lose weight for a while, and then inevitably you'll go off of it and gain it all back.

I remember doing it for a couple of months, lost about 17 pounds, gained it all back and more when I went off of it. Off course I am back on something similar now, but that is for health reasons.
 

Cadaver

Senior member
Feb 19, 2002
344
0
0
Pardon my misspelling...
I know what the "diet" is. What I was asking for, but I guess I didn't make myself clear enough, was people's personal experiences with it.
I've got the books, and I've talked to my neighbors (a couple have been on it), but I wanted other personal stories.

If you've been on it, please tell me what you thought. If not, I don't need links to websites.
 

XMan

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
12,513
50
91
Originally posted by: Cadaver
Pardon my misspelling...
I know what the "diet" is. What I was asking for, but I guess I didn't make myself clear enough, was people's personal experiences with it.
I've got the books, and I've talked to my neighbors (a couple have been on it), but I wanted other personal stories.

If you've been on it, please tell me what you thought. If not, I don't need links to websites.

I've lost 32 pounds in a month. I feel great.

PM Wingznut and ask him to let you into our private topic, there's a hell of a lot less disinformation than you get in OT.
 

Cadaver

Senior member
Feb 19, 2002
344
0
0
Originally posted by: SWScorch

I know you said you're in an exercise plan; good for you. I'm not specifically targeting you with my post; it just reminded me of all these people who do stuff like this. Seriously, you dont need to go on any diet except one: stay away from fast food and soda, eat home-cooked meals, and run a few times a week and you'll be fine.

I know you're not targeting me, but my situation is a bit different.
I've been on chemotherapy for the last 20 weeks for Hodgkin's disease (just recently finished). One interesting side-effect for many people on the combination of drugs I was on (called "ABVD" for short) is weight gain, and not weight loss like you'd expect on most other therapies. It's not water-retention or due to effects of corticosteriods, but it had a direct effect on my appetite. I was always hungry.

While I've never been a "hard-body", I've never been this heavy, either. I have a black-belt in Choi Kwang Do martial arts and I've been doing it continuously for the last 4 years. Excercise alone isn't going to help me loose what I've put on. I need some dietary help. I'm decreasing my caloric intake, but also trying to cut the carbs. This is essentially what Atkins (see, I spelled it correctly this time) is.

So, gee, sorry if it's a repost Oreo... but there are plenty of topics that come up frequently in conversation... its not like this thread was the first already posted topic.
 

Wingznut

Elite Member
Dec 28, 1999
16,968
2
0
Cadaver, I have added you to the thread going in Private Topics. There are over 400 posts of (mostly) great information.... Check it out. :)

Please check with your doctor first. I'm fairly sure that nobody here would have an idea how well this would fit in with your situation.

Btw, how is your battle with Hodgkin's going? I can't even imagine what that must be like.
 

Cadaver

Senior member
Feb 19, 2002
344
0
0
Thanks, Wingznut... I'll check it out.

And as for my handle... well, I got that a few years ago trying to play Unreal Tournament against a few friends. I kind of sucked, and they kept nailing me. So they called me cadaver, since that's what I was for most of the game :) It just kind of stuck I guess.

And as for treatment, I'm going very well actually. Stage I disease, so treatment isn't so terrible (could be worse). And better than 85% chance of complete cure :)
 

Ranger X

Lifer
Mar 18, 2000
11,218
1
0
Originally posted by: TwinkleToes77
atkins isnt a diet.. its a change of habit.. It cuts your carbs down to a very low level for 2 weeks and then you slowly increase them each week until you reach your limit your body can handle before turning back into fat and gaining weight. I've done the atkins thing but im a slave to carbs and i couldnt last more than 1 week on it. GOTTA HAVE MY BREAD.
You can eat whole wheat bread instead of white bread. It won't eliminate the carbs but it's better for you.
 

Wingznut

Elite Member
Dec 28, 1999
16,968
2
0
Originally posted by: Cadaver
And as for treatment, I'm going very well actually. Stage I disease, so treatment isn't so terrible (could be worse). And better than 85% chance of complete cure :)
Good to hear! :)
Originally posted by: Ranger X
Originally posted by: TwinkleToes77
atkins isnt a diet.. its a change of habit.. It cuts your carbs down to a very low level for 2 weeks and then you slowly increase them each week until you reach your limit your body can handle before turning back into fat and gaining weight. I've done the atkins thing but im a slave to carbs and i couldnt last more than 1 week on it. GOTTA HAVE MY BREAD.
You can eat whole wheat bread instead of white bread. It won't eliminate the carbs but it's better for you.
You'd never get into ketosis in the first couple of weeks, if you ate bread. Two slices of whole wheat bread has ~34 grams of carbs in it, which is way over the 20g/day guideline.
 

imported_Papi

Platinum Member
Nov 15, 2002
2,413
0
0
Originally posted by: TwinkleToes77
atkins isnt a diet.. its a change of habit.. It cuts your carbs down to a very low level for 2 weeks and then you slowly increase them each week until you reach your limit your body can handle before turning back into fat and gaining weight. I've done the atkins thing but im a slave to carbs and i couldnt last more than 1 week on it. GOTTA HAVE MY BREAD.

Aye!