<<
I was at a party last weekend and got a tad bit drunk. I got 3 girls' phone numbers. The problem is that I didn't write down their names with the numbers. I'm not sure which number is for which girl. I would like to call back one of these girls but what if I accidentally call back one of the other two?
>>
Call them all up and be honest with them. Chances are if you really were drunk, then they'd recall you being drunk to begin with and it would come as no surprise to them. Just call them up and say, "Hi, I'm
GL you mgiht remember yourself giving me your phone number, but I was too drunk to get down your beautiful name"

chances are if you are honest and sincere (don't necessarily say what I just stated) that you'd get the girl to be nice in return.
They must have seen something in you to begin with to give you their numbers in the first place. The only thing that you don't want to happen is that they say, "Oh, sorry bub, but I was just as drunk as you that night, who are you again?"
Good luck on the situation though - only thing you can do is call - don't sit around doing nothing
)(GG)