Originally posted by: Goosemaster
Originally posted by: Iron Woode
Originally posted by: ViRGE
Originally posted by: MadCowDisease
Ever seen a car crash between an old steel Buick (the ones that weigh like 4000 pounds) and a modern Ford Escort? Let's just say that the Buick had a few scratches.
That's not a "cheaper" thing, that's a "safer" thing. Physics dictates that force is the product of mass and acceleration; if you make a car that crumples like that, it will take longer to stop, reducing the acceleration, and in turn reducing the force. An old car may survive, but at high speeds, you're the one who's going to be squashed like a bug instead.
Not really.
I have been in large old steel cars and got hit hard. I walked away with no injuries. The other guy wasn't so lucky. New cars may crumple but you pay the price when they cut you out like a sardin in a can. Old steel cars with full frames always do better in crash tests. That frame absorbes lots of collision energy and gives a much safer shell to be in. Old cars with crappy seatbelts cause more problems.
I tell you what. How I about I run into your car at 60mph with my 1987 Crown Vic and see who gets squashed like a bug? And we will also see which car can be fixed cheaper.
#1 car in crash tests is the Ford Crown Vic and Grand Marquis. Full frame is the main reason.
THat's nice dear, but you are leaving out one key factor

redictability. Although in your situation, the force of the accident was not sufficient to over power the steel, imgaine if it had been. Although cars today are made of lighter and seemingly "weaker" materials, they still provide a great deal of safety. Crumple zones allow you to dissapate forces before they reach your compartment. With your old steel car, you could be fine, or just as easily have a severed foot because the engine compartment shifted a little, and a big piece of metal was forced into the driver's area.
for small to moderate incidents, old steel vehicles are king when it comes to vehicle frame survivability. However, the safety of the occupants is left up to chance in such a situation. At least with modern day cars, a multitude of engineers have designed it so that forces will be dissapated as much as possible to save the occupants, regardless of the cost of repairing the car.