9200 SE vs 4600ti

[SuperU21]

I've got some friends who need upgrades and I've got a 9800xt lying around and a 4600ti...

I'm just wondering based on what you guys know which are better for each friend. Ideally I want to give the 5900U I trade for to the guy who has the 9200 SE but that may not happen but I do have a 4600ti lying around.

Thanks

 

[dug777]

4600ti pwns 9200 SE

9800XT>5900U

 

[n7]

Originally posted by: dug777
4600ti pwns 9200 SE

9800XT>5900U

Yup.

 

[Mik3y]

Originally posted by: n7

Originally posted by: dug777
4600ti pwns 9200 SE

9800XT>5900U

Yup.

SE stands for sh!tty editon. no where near the performance of a plain 9200.

 

[SuperU21]

Oh, what about a regular 9200 vs 4600ti... since I'm not 100% sure if its SE or not

 

[imported_Kiwi]

Originally posted by: SuperU21
Oh, what about a regular 9200 vs 4600ti... since I'm not 100% sure if its SE or not

Match each pair at GPUreview in their "Compare" function. But I can tell you that no Radeon numbered lower than 9600 in the 9xxx series could touch a Ti 4600, and that would've been the 9600 Pro, and the 9600-plain was somewhat slower, but it has Dx9 capability, which nVidia did not until the 6xxx's. I can't recall if any 9500's were better than Dx8 (I put the 9500 Pro up against the Ti 4600).

http://www.gpureview.com/show_cards.php?card1=135&card2=27

OK, I actually paused to READ that "Compare Pair" page, and the 9500 Pro has Dx9.