• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

800 Mhz P4's = no big deal?

Jeff7181

Lifer
I'm kinda curious as to why everybody's making such a huge deal about the 800 Mhz FSB... when it's actually a 200 Mhz FSB quad pumped.
Granted it has arrived before AMD's 400 mhz FSB processors... but I still fail to see what the big deal is.
One might consider it compensating for a fault in the P4's design... longer pipeline makes the CPU's performance more dependant on the speed of the FSB and the RAM so they have to pump up the speed of the FSB and make you use faster RAM.

Responses welcome, no flames please.
 
Why not make faster CPU's? AMD is getting so blown out of the water they had to resort to a lame PR rating.

It just like the men who are short saying it's not the size that counts, but how you use it 😀😀... the absolutely the dumbest thing I ever heard
rolleye.gif

That is exactly what AMD is 'saying'...

But don't get me wrong. If push comes to shove, I'd build an AMD system... even though it costs the same to build either way.
 
remember, they also have HT which helps video encoding............too bad i'm too poor to get one🙁
 
Originally posted by: bgeh
remember, they also have HT which helps video encoding............too bad i'm too poor to get one🙁

Id still buy AMD if I had cash. Even though Intel are 'winning', AMD's competition can only be healthy to the business and no matter how small my contribution, at least i can say I helped to promote healthy competition.
 
Originally posted by: bgeh
remember, they also have HT which helps video encoding............too bad i'm too poor to get one🙁
Who cares about hyper threading? I'm asking for opinions on the 800 Mhz FSB.

Why not make faster CPU's? AMD is getting so blown out of the water they had to resort to a lame PR rating.
I'm not asking about the speed of the CPU either.

It just like the men who are short saying it's not the size that counts, but how you use it ... the absolutely the dumbest thing I ever heard
That is exactly what AMD is 'saying'...
But don't get me wrong. If push comes to shove, I'd build an AMD system... even though it costs the same to build either way.
Also nothing to do with my request for opinions on the FSB.
 
Okay, with the small caches 800fsb was not as big of a deal as people thought it would be
rolleye.gif
But who cares? I don't... Bartons were duds also.
It's a up and down ladder on both sides.
 
Should also not that people are going to OC these 200fsb CPU's (AMD and Intel both).
Memory will continue to get better, and perhaps with people raving that they want memory to goto 300+ fsb to keep up with CPU instead of using dividers, imagine what will happen for PC3200 memory... its already starting 😀.
 
BUT... isn't 533FSB is 133 Quad Pumped?
133->200 is a big deal to me. 77 points increase in FSB is big deal.
 
BUT... isn't 533FSB is 133 Quad Pumped?
Yes it is.

133->200 is a big deal to me. 77 points increase in FSB is big deal.
For the most part yes.

Intel released the P4's with small multipliers. Based on people's OC's... they might as well as released them all the way to 3.6GHz or higher. Or even the magical 4GHz even if it only would be on paper for select OEM's :Q.
 
So you think the 200 Mhz (actual) FSB is something to get excited about?

Too bad you can't do a competative comparison with P4 as easily as XP's. I'd like to see benchmarks of processors of equal Mhz, but using a 133 Mhz bus, a 166 Mhz bus, and a 200 Mhz bus.
 
Off hand I can not really find anything conclusive. We'll just have to wait another week or so when they are more available in the US.
 
Just so ya know... I'm testing my FSB at 221 Mhz right now, 221x10=2210 Mhz (my XP2500)

few more tests should provide enough proof for me that it's stable, and then I'll go for more =)
 
It didn't like 221... now I'm testing at 220... and it's stable so far (didn't fail Prime 95 like it did at 221)
 
Originally posted by: Jeff7181
So you think the 200 Mhz (actual) FSB is something to get excited about?

Too bad you can't do a competative comparison with P4 as easily as XP's. I'd like to see benchmarks of processors of equal Mhz, but using a 133 Mhz bus, a 166 Mhz bus, and a 200 Mhz bus.
Its been done all over the web. You only need to go to the main page
The 533 MHz FSB 3.06 and the 800 MHz 3.0 are compared.
 
no 166 Mhz bus in there... 133 and 200, but no 166... I'd be curious to see if a 166 Mhz bus is half way in between, or if it's about the same as 200. (cause eventually you're gonna reach a point where you could have the FSB running at such a high speed, it doesn't make a difference anymore.)
 
Well, since Intel doesn't make a 667 MHz FSB CPU, it would be kind of difficult to review one. You can extrapolate the difference as being in between the 533 and 800 if you wish.
 
That wouldn't be accurate though... I realize Athlon XP's aren't as dependant on memory bandwidth as P4's are, but Athlon XP's don't show a whole lot of improvement at the same clock sp eed by going to a 200 Mhz bus, especially if your RAM isn't running in sync with the FSB.
If it doesn't make a difference with P4's either, then maybe it's a smart move by them to set the foundation for future (faster) processors... but, my question is, would a P4 see a performance boost with a 200 Mhz bus vs. a 166 mhz bus.

I know lots of people out there run higher than a 166 Mhz bus, but I'm curious, at equal clock speeds, does anything more than a 166 Mhz bus make a difference in performance? Would be hard to test I guess since the multipliers are locked on P4's aren't they?
 
People are already overclocking the P4 800 MHz FSB CPUs past 1200 MHz and the performance keeps on scaleing higher. It seems the more FSB, the better.
 
Originally posted by: oldfart
People are already overclocking the P4 800 MHz FSB CPUs past 1200 MHz and the performance keeps on scaleing higher. It seems the more FSB, the better.

At the same clock speed though? Of course if you increase the FSB without changing the multiplier it will score higher.
 
Its not really that hard to undertand.

Same CPU MHz @ higher FSB = faster system.

Simple as that. You cant think of it in AMD terms.
 
I doubt if you have a 3 Ghz FSB with a multiplier of 1, and a 1.5 Ghz FSB with a multiplier of 2 you'd see a difference in performance. There is a limit to how high a FSB is useful, I'm asking what that limit is.
 
What are you talking about???

Read again:

Same CPU MHz @ higher FSB = faster system.

Simple as that. You cant think of it in AMD terms.

Its been tested here a few times. You probably dont read the Intel threads. Thugsrook and some others did testing on P4 mobile chips and had them up to 225 FSB. The P4C 800 Mhz FSB chips show the same thing. Higher FSB @ same CPU speed = more performance.

I dont know why you are questioning a proven concept. Put down your blinders, read some reviews and threads. Its all there in black and white.

Better yet, get yourself a P4 rig and test it yourself 😉
 
You read again...

I doubt if you have a 3 Ghz FSB with a multiplier of 1, and a 1.5 Ghz FSB with a multiplier of 2 you'd see a difference in performance. There is a limit to how high a FSB is useful, I'm asking what that limit is.
 
Why do you think there is a limit? From all P4 testing I've seen up to 1200+ MHz FSB, performance increases. Why would it stop? 400->533->800 all had performance increase. There are already plans for future Intel chips with 1200 MHz FSB.

So to answer your original topic:
800 Mhz P4's = no big deal?
No. It is a big deal.
 
Back
Top