680 Ohm Resistor Getting Hot.

Nov 17, 2019
10,627
6,362
136
I have a 12VDC supply feeding a standard discrete LED about 40 feet away. Wire is 24G copper (telephone type cable). Resistor packaging calls for a 680 ohm resistor which I had on hand and installed. But it's getting hot to the touch, almost too hot. LED is working, but may be a bit bright.

Do I change the resistor to higher value or lower? I have some 470s and 330s as well as 1Ks and higher.

All are 1/4 watt.
 

[DHT]Osiris

Lifer
Dec 15, 2015
13,969
12,012
146
I have a 12VDC supply feeding a standard discrete LED about 40 feet away. Wire is 24G copper (telephone type cable). Resistor packaging calls for a 680 ohm resistor which I had on hand and installed. But it's getting hot to the touch, almost too hot. LED is working, but may be a bit bright.

Do I change the resistor to higher value or lower? I have some 470s and 330s as well as 1Ks and higher.

All are 1/4 watt.
Going about this all wrong, make a little liquid cooling loop for the resistor!
 

Red Squirrel

No Lifer
May 24, 2003
67,135
11,997
126
www.anyf.ca
You will just need a higher wattage resistor, maybe 5w.

Another option is to slightly reduce the voltage of the power supply as that will reduce the amount of current the resistor needs to bleed off. Basically LEDs need a constant current source and not a constant voltage source, so a cheap way to do this is to introduce a resistor which bleeds off some current. Its basically a cheap way to do it without needing a constant current power supply.
 

pcgeek11

Lifer
Jun 12, 2005
21,251
4,385
136
Use a heat sink.

hs-heatsink.197c5fe6ae7d3d7d1f8cb3b2b0decd61.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: [DHT]Osiris

bba-tcg

Senior member
Apr 8, 2010
568
275
136
computerguyonline.net
I have a 12VDC supply feeding a standard discrete LED about 40 feet away. Wire is 24G copper (telephone type cable). Resistor packaging calls for a 680 ohm resistor which I had on hand and installed. But it's getting hot to the touch, almost too hot. LED is working, but may be a bit bright.

Do I change the resistor to higher value or lower? I have some 470s and 330s as well as 1Ks and higher.

All are 1/4 watt.
The best way would be to use a higher wattage resistor. 12 volts with a 680 watt resistor dissipates slightly over .21 watts. Your 1/4 resistor will do it, but be hot to the touch. A one watt resistor would run cooler.

P=VI or (V^2)/R =144/680 = .211765 watts.

Two 330 ohm resistors in series will do the job too, but look less elegant, depending upon the way you have to mount the resistors.
 

VashHT

Diamond Member
Feb 1, 2007
3,058
865
136
If you want it to be dimmer up the resistance, you're pulling close to 1/4 watt like others said so it'll be a bit hot. I'd agree with Sick Willie just go for a higher wattage resistor, they're like less than a cent on digikey.
 

shortylickens

No Lifer
Jul 15, 2003
82,854
17,365
136
If you wanna use the same resistance, they do make larger bodies that can dissipate 1/2 watt or even 1 watt.
OR you can do some kind of active or passive cooling.
OR you can use something with HIGHER resistance, which lowers current flow. Which reduces heat. But also fucks up your circuit, which was designed and build by somebody much smarter than you.
 
Nov 17, 2019
10,627
6,362
136
Switched to a 1K. Still warm to the touch, but not as hot. May go up a bit more yet. It's just a pilot indicator. It doesn't need to be bright, just enough to know it's on.
 

bba-tcg

Senior member
Apr 8, 2010
568
275
136
computerguyonline.net
Higher resistance increases heat.

You'd think so, but consider this:

Using the same formula from above: P=VI or (V^2)/R, if you had a voltage of 12v and a resistance of 12 ohms, you would have: (12*12)/12 = 12 watts.

Now if you had 12v and 144 ohms: (12*12)/144 = 1 watt.

Which is going to produce more heat?

And that formula is right there on the page you linked. It's obvious that the higher the resistance, the lower the power consumption.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PowerEngineer