• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

3rd Party Flashes? (was a Lens question)

R

RKS

Diamond Member
I have a Canon T1i with the following lenses:
EF 50mm f/1.8 II
EF-S 18-55mm (kit lens)
EF-S 55-250mm (kit lens)

I am far from a good photographer and have plenty other hobbies that take up my time and money so I don’t want to spend a lot. Most of my photography is of my kids. I love the 50mm but sometimes the prime lens doesn’t allow me to capture a larger field. The 18-55 is nice too but it isn’t as sharp as the 50mm. So I am looking for a relatively cheap lens (under $300 new or used) that would be my best choice. Am I better off getting another prime or zoom lens or am I SOL at my price range? Is my money better spent toward a quality flash?

Thanks for any help.
 
Last edited:
A flash that you can bounce will give you the best bang for your buck. I'd get a 430EX II if you want to stick with Canon - they cost about $265 refurbished, direct from Canon. If you want to keep it really cheap there are also some 3rd party flashes available like the Yongnuo YN468 that work with Canon's ETTL system. You can find these for around $100 or less and many people get good results from them, but the build quality is generally pretty poor and you never know if it will keep working after a camera firmware upgrade.

The 18-55mm IS is actually not a bad lens optically, and using it with a flash will make it more versatile. If you do end up looking for a normal zoom with a larger aperture, the previously mentioned Tamron 17-50mm is the best "budget" choice IMO. It's sharp and cheap.

The 30mm f/1.4 Sigma and 28mm f/1.8 Canon are commonly recommended affordable wider primes on crop, but with kids, I think fast primes are tough to use in available light, particularly if they are at the age where they are moving around a lot. If motion blur isn't an issue, thin DOF might be. I often end up grabbing a flash anyway, and if I'm doing that I'd rather have the versatility of a zoom.
 
1) congrats on obtaining the unholy trinity 😛 i hope you put it to good use and use it to realize what limitations you may or may not have in whatever compositions you use the most.
2) what do you want to achieve? do you want another zoom or another prime? would you be willing to sell some (or all) of your lenses to compensate for additional cost?

things you could get for around $300-$400:

zooms:
canon ef-s 17-85mm f/4.0-5.6
canon ef-s 18-135mm f/3.5-5.6
tamron 17-50mm f/2.8
sigma 17-70mm f/2.8-4.0

primes:
canon ef 85mm f/1.8
canon ef 50mm f/1.4
canon ef 28mm f/1.8
canon ef 35mm f/2.0
sigma 30mm f/1.4

THE POWER IS YOURS! (yours.. yours.. yours...)
 
A flash is critical for kid photos IMHO. You really need fast shutter and unless posed, not wide-open. The light in your home is a LOT less than you really need to photograph them. The on-cam flash is just a joke. A flash will really give you options.

Recall that the photographer takes the pictures and creates the art, not the camera, its lenses, or any of his equipment. Gear is a tool like paintbrushes and canvas.

I find the 18-55 unusable anymore - (got it originally in I think 2007 with the digital rebel xt). I've completely outgrown it. Its fine for snapshots but for any really sharp or impressive shots I move straight to the primes. Even the 55-250 is too slow to be of much use without high iso. IMO the 50mm f/1.8 II is excellent for studies or stuff like flowers and textures. I find it too narrow for people inside and anything that isn't right up close loses its awesome sharpness.

Of the ones in this thread, I find the 85mm prime my favorite, but I'm not a people person. My wife loves it for portraits but folks usually find it odd that shes on the other side of the room to get a 3/4 shot.

One of these day's she'll pick up the 28 or 35mm prime that I keep telling her she needs...
 
So after reading these responses I've decided to get a 430EX II flash since the 580EX II is probably overkill for me. Are there comparable off-brands or is the $270 worth it for the Canon Speedlite. I see a bunch of cheap knock-offs on DealExtreme.
 
Last edited:
RKS said:
So after reading these responses I've decided to get a 430EX II flash since the 580EX II is probably overkill for me. Are there comparable off-brands or is the $270 worth it for the Canon Speedlite. I see a bunch of cheap knock-offs on DealExtreme.
Click to expand...
Most off brand flashes are not TTL and/or have slow cycling time.You have to manually adjust the camera fstop to the flash fstop which itn't that big of a deal even if it doesn't have TTL. And, some off-brand flashes are even more powerful that Canon flashes, and they tend to be much cheaper as well.

My 2 Vivitar 285HV flashes (more than 20 year old, great for outdoor fill flash, macro work, and studio) combine cost is roughly 1/2 of my 430EX, and they work perfectly even for fill flash.
 
Last edited:
i would get a yongnuo flash first. The YongNuo YN-565EX is the current top of line flash but you can also look for cheaper models in the yongnuo line.
 
iGas said:
Most off brand flashes are not TTL and/or have slow cycling time.You have to manually adjust the camera fstop to the flash fstop which itn't that big of a deal even if it doesn't have TTL. And, some off-brand flashes are even more powerful that Canon flashes, and they tend to be much cheaper as well.

My 2 Vivitar 285HV flashes (more than 20 year old, great for outdoor fill flash, macro work, and studio) combine cost is roughly 1/2 of my 430EX, and they work perfectly even for fill flash.
Click to expand...

elitejp said:
i would get a yongnuo flash first. The YongNuo YN-565EX is the current top of line flash but you can also look for cheaper models in the yongnuo line.
Click to expand...

Lotheron said:
I echo the Yongnuo suggestion. They get rave reviews for the price. I have a YN-468 and I love it.

You can check out http://speedlights.net/ for reviews.
Click to expand...


Thanks for the suggestions. I found the 565 for $150. Hopefully it's here for the holidays.
 
also a very good flash
To the op: ive been eying the 565 for a while now. Just waiting for some extra funds before I buy.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top