37-40" LCD TVs - Are they pretty much all equal?

Dec 10, 2005
27,946
12,493
136
I'm looking at getting an LCD tv for my apartment sometime in the next month or two. Are most TVs in the 37-40" LCD range equal? I wanted something that was 1080p and not too expensive (looking to spend at most $600). It would mainly be used for antenna TV, movies, and maybe internet video (if I ever hook up a laptop to it).

Any recommendations on what to look for or stuff to stay away from?

Thanks
 

s44

Diamond Member
Oct 13, 2006
9,427
16
81
Even most Manhattan apartments allow 6' of distance. That means 42".
 
Dec 10, 2005
27,946
12,493
136
Is there a big difference between 40" and 42"? Anything I should look for in terms of features? Best time to buy? Brands to steer clear of?
 

s44

Diamond Member
Oct 13, 2006
9,427
16
81
Well, over a whole square foot of screen space. ;)

Different manufacturers and different product lines hit different sizes -- e.g. Samsung makes 40", LG 42". 42" also puts you in the range of plasma, which uses more electricity and throws more heat (an actual concern in some NYC spaces), but generally has better black levels (contrast). Downside of plasma: reflective screen means you need a light-controlled viewing space. Some people prefer LCD colors, some plasma.

There are two LCD features of note: 120hz (or 240hz) and LED backlighting. 120hz allows motion interpolation to make movies and other film content look "smoother" (most people dislike this), as well as sporting events (people generally like this). It also allows perfect 5:5 pulldown of 24hz film content, which lets you see each frame of a movie for the same amount of time (instead of alternating one frame 3x, the next 2x, the next 3x etc.). LED backlighting makes the set thinner, and the "local dimming" variety offers plasma-like contrast levels.

Your price range rules out LED, and very likely 120hz as well. Given that, I'd seriously consider plasma (like this Panny). But make sure whatever set you get is true 1080p -- sitting close up means you'll need every bit of resolution.

edit: note that 5:5 is an *alternative* to motion interpolation (smoothing). But 120hz/240hz covers both features (600hz on plasmas is a fake "feature" that has nothing to do with this).
 
Last edited:

velillen

Platinum Member
Jul 12, 2006
2,120
1
81
unless s44 is talking about somethign else i dont notice any heat with my plasma. its a panny TC-P42C2. Just played ps3 for an hour and felt the back and it was cool to the touch in some spots and mildly warm (barely above room temp) over the "grates"
 

s44

Diamond Member
Oct 13, 2006
9,427
16
81
Yeah, 42" doesn't make as much difference as with the larger sizes. FWIW, the Panny S2 Plasma I linked is rated for 300W power consumption, while the LG 42LD450 LCD is at 180W and the Panny L42U22 LCD at 93W (!).
 
Dec 10, 2005
27,946
12,493
136
Thanks for the input. I'll keep a look out for a good deal in the coming weeks on something in the 42" range.
 
Dec 10, 2005
27,946
12,493
136
At 42", should I consider any 720P sets? The viewing distance will be about 5-6 feet and source material would either be standard DVDs (maybe upconverted), material from the internet (Hulu stuff) or OTA TV.

Though, if this Panasonic stays on sale, I may just pick it up... Is there a good time to buy them as well, such as just before Black Friday?
 
Last edited:

s44

Diamond Member
Oct 13, 2006
9,427
16
81
At 42", should I consider any 720P sets? The viewing distance will be about 5-6 feet
Absolutely not.

BF or thereabouts is usually the best time to buy, but the big sales may not be on the exact unit you're looking at. Plus, you know, a month and a half more of HD football games...
 
Dec 10, 2005
27,946
12,493
136
Absolutely not.

BF or thereabouts is usually the best time to buy, but the big sales may not be on the exact unit you're looking at. Plus, you know, a month and a half more of HD football games...

I'm not tied to any particular set. That's just the cheapest 42" 1080p set I've seen (among both plasma and LCD). I'll probably wait a till closer to BF, watch weekly sales online and such, to get something, though I'm not going to buy anything in store (fighting in line to get the best deals). I'm in no rush to buy one.
 
Last edited:

s44

Diamond Member
Oct 13, 2006
9,427
16
81
There are lots of 60hz LCDs below that price, including the 2 I mentioned above. Check teh internets.
 
Dec 10, 2005
27,946
12,493
136
I ended up ordering the LG 42LD450 from Amazon for ~$500 (w/ free delivery). I should have it sometime early in the second week of November. Thanks again for the help.