As the families of South Park gather at church on Sunday,
Stan (who has a cast following his injuries from the previous episode) questions why he has to go to Church every week. His parents admonish him on the importance of church, with
Sharon saying that it makes her feel better. At church,
Father Maxi struggles to deliver his sermon amid all the constant interruptions by members of the congregation who make jokes referencing
Catholic Church sexual abuse cases. Butters attempts to console Maxi, relating to him how he has been the subject of ridicule at school, but now enjoys greater popularity. Encouraging him not to cover in shame, he invites Maxi to board game night with Stan and his friend's at Stan's house, but Maxi's appearance there garners more ridicule from Randy, who finds the scene of a Catholic priest sitting with five boys worthy of a photograph on social media. When an embarrassed Maxi leaves, Butter goes after him. Saying that he himself "used to be" Father Maxi, Butters implores him not to allow himself to be daunted by the cruelty of others, and to simply be himself.
As a result of this, Maxi spends more time socializing with Butters, to the point that churchgoers find the church doors locked the following Sunday. When
Mr. Mackey alerts the diocese that "another" priest has disappeared from his parish, the diocease sends a cleanup crew of church officials to thoroughly clean the South Park church, Stan's house, and any other location where Father Maxi has been, in order to remove trace evidence of child molestation. At Clyde's birthday party at a roller rink, Butters brings Maxi, much to the anger of Clyde, who does not want a priest at his party. A demoralized Maxi leaves with Butters, and later confesses him that some time ago, he learned the extent of the Catholic Church sex abuse problem, and that it was worse than anyone thought (as seen in "
Red Hot Catholic Love"). When the cleanup crew appear there to continue their task, and learn that Maxi was there with a child, Butters, they kidnap Stan and Clyde, and after tracking him down, Butters as well.
The cleanup crew take the three boys into the woods, where they have deployed a
Zamboni ice resurfacer modified to clean up semen, or "Cumboni". Father Maxi tracks them down and confronts the cleanup crew, telling them to do whatever they want to him, but to spare the children. Surprised, the bishop in charge says that they are not there to kill him, but to cover up his crimes and issue him a transfer to the
Maldives. Assuring him that no one will bother him there, and that other Catholic priests will take over for him in South Park, Father Maxi uses the Cumboni to trample the cleanup crew to death. He returns to his position at South Park's church, delivering his sermons despite the continued jokes at the expense of the church.