5000 mile Continental DWS update: Loveing the tires so far. Had them right about 3 months now with a little over 5000 miles on them. Still as quiet as the day they were put on. I ran the first couple thousand miles at 34-35 psi and the last 3000 around 38-40. Closer to 38 mostly. I've had only two hard rain days to test them in the wet.
35psi: Felt very nice on the ride side and absorbed the bumps and road imperfections magnificantly. Just a touch softer than I like and gives the car a slight roll feel in hard turns because of the sidewall on the tire. Ride quietness has improved immensely as well as grip. No rain test because it was dry the whole time.
38-39pis: It's amazing how much 3-4 psi difference can make. The car feels like a whole new animal now. Still a fairly smooth ride, but much more firm and sporty feeling. I really like the way the car feels as a whole and the feedback in the steering wheel is increased nicely. In hard turns the car just sticks. Much firmer without that slight roll feel and the car feels much more flickable and nimble. Sound has just slightly increased with air pressure, but went back to normal on a lower psi test run. Car is still quieter than previous tires. Had two heavy rain tests. Car hooked up almost as if it weren't even wet. I could barely feel any slipping at all even though it was the first real rain in a couple months. Much better wet handeling than my old tires. Can't wait to give the snow a go.
Overall impressions are very positive. Thanks for all the great suggestions. I will definitely be recommending these tires. After 5k miles they still look new and I can't see any visible wear. Tires will be rotated in the next 500-1000 miles. Whenever I get time to take it in. They are not sport tires by any means but IMO have an almost perfect balance between performance, quietness, mileage warranty, and wet/dry performance. They are simply a great all around tire.