- Jun 30, 2004
- 16,180
- 1,780
- 126
LA TIMES Obituary to follow my comment here]
That phrase – “Baby Killer” – became additional ammunition in political confrontations about the Viet Nam War. But Lt. Calley labelled himself, in his own words, by his own admission. Jane Fonda? She’s still alive at 85, but that observation alone shouldn’t have any bearing on the topic.
There should be a consensus today about wasting $1 Trillion or more and sacrificing 59,000 Americans and 2 million Asians – countless more wounded, based on the facts, based on the history, based on all the circumstances, and the simple truth that nineteen years of war (1954-1975) yielded nothing but the same outcome if Johnson had not followed the Joint Chiefs in expanding the war during the mid- ‘60s. LBJ might instead have simply followed the dictates of JFK’s NSAM (National Security Action Memorandum) #263. But you will still find people insisting that it wasn’t a mistake, perhaps owing to a general public misunderstanding of George Kennan’s white-paper written for the JCS during the late 1940s. The general public, after all, had never heard of George Kennan nor ever read his strategic doctrine.
Just by asking those particular people questions to assess their knowledge – for instance, “who created the Saigon Military Mission in 1952?” or “Who became the manufactured constituency for Ngo Dinh Diem?” – you can quickly conclude which opinion is grounded in the greatest ignorance or conversely – accumulated understanding.
It deserves emphasis that concluding a mistake has nothing to do with the honor deserved by most of our men who served. But the naysayers never fail to interject dishonor to our troops as synonymous with the growing conclusion about the war.
What is also very interesting is a prediction made by the famous Longshoreman turned college professor – Eric Hoffer, author of the book “True Believer”. He argued that pulling out of Viet Nam, even as late and delayed the decision to do so, was also a mistake, suggesting that the reversal would eventually lead to an era of shifting public opinion and ascendant fascism generations later.
Decide yourselves whether or not his prediction came true, or that it somehow negates the appropriate choice in face of the original mistake. Just as troubling, “True Believer” describes a phenomenon of today’s politics parallel to the prediction about public opinion. Personally, I’m done with it, inasmuch as old friends no longer suffer so much from their PTSD – waking at 3AM with nightmares, shrieking in puddles of sweat. But make no mistake: whether drafted or draft-dodger, student-deferred or willfully-enlisted, gung-ho or conscientious objector, man or woman – the war had an indelible effect on all of us who had come of age in the mid-1960s – and perhaps many, many more, even if they had yet to be born.
WILLIAM CALLEY, 1943 – 2024 [LA TIMES, 8-1-2024]
Soldier convicted in My Lai massacre in Vietnam
‘I AM VERY SORRY’. Lt. William Calley said he was just following orders to kill everyone but years later expressed remorse. (Joe Holloway, Jr. Associated Press)
By Steve Chawkins
The night before 2nd Lt. William Calley shipped out of Hawaii to Vietnam, he was obliged to read his unit a list of rules regarding their behavior in a new land.
The men were arrayed in a horseshoe around the 5-foot-3, boyish-looking officer as he recited the do’s and don’ts from the Pentagon publication “Vietnam, Our Host.” In his 1971 memoir, he remembered items such as “Do not insult the women … do not assault the women. And — I’m too foggy about it. Items like ‘Be polite.’ ”
“I had only three minutes for Vietnam, Our Host,” he wrote. “I did a very, very poor job.”
Three-and-a-half months later, 24-year-old “Rusty” Calley was at the center of the My Lai massacre, one of the darkest chapters in U.S. military history. In a hamlet that reputedly had been a Viet Cong stronghold, Calley and the men he commanded shot, stabbed, raped, and hurled hand grenades at hundreds of residents later deemed to be unarmed civilians — mostly women, children and elderly men.
Calley, who was convicted of murder in a 1971 court-martial that was widely seen as a trial of the Vietnam War itself, died on April 28, according to his Florida death record, which said he had been living in an apartment in Gainesville. He was 80.
After My Lai, Calley was sentenced to life at hard labor. However, owing to the intervention of President Nixon, he served only a few months in prison before being released to house arrest. During three years of appeals, he lived in a bachelor-quarters apartment at Ft. Benning, Ga.
Military authorities and then-Secretary of the Army Howard Callaway reduced his sentence to 20 years, and then 10. In 1974, he was paroled.
By then, Calley had gained millions of supporters. The White House was flooded with more than 300,000 letters and telegrams denouncing his life sentence. A Gallup poll indicated that 79% of Americans believed he had been made a scapegoat.
After his conviction, a popular song based on “The Battle Hymn of The Republic” — “The Battle Hymn of Lt. Calley” — sold more than a million records : “My name is William Calley / I’m a soldier of this land / I’ve tried to do my duty and to gain the upper hand / But they’ve made me out a villain / They have stamped me with a brand / As we go marching on …”
Even some leaders of the antiwar movement thought Calley had been treated unfairly. “It’s too bad that one man is being made to pay for the brutality of the whole war,” said Dr. Benjamin Spock , the late activist and pediatrician whose books were child-raising bibles for frazzled American parents.
In his memoir, Calley portrayed himself as an easy target for officials trying to sanitize the unpopular war. Once the story of My Lai emerged, “the American government couldn’t say, ‘Oh, that’s how it is in Vietnam, everyone,’ ” He wrote. “It had to protect two million veterans and 200 million Americans. It had to tell everyone, ‘A mad killer did it.’ ”
On March 16, 1968, Calley led one of the three platoons of Charlie Company into the village known by U.S. military planners as My Lai 4. Four hours after their arrival, most of the villagers were dead. At least nine girls and women had been raped and mutilated. “Zippo squads, using their cigarette lighters to ignite thatched rooves, burned down 246 homes. Bodies were dumped down wells. Even the livestock was shot.
At the My Lai museum outside Da Nang in Vietnam — formally known as the Son My War Remnant Site — a marble plaque lists 504 victims by name. Of the 273 women killed, 17 were pregnant. One hundred and sixty victims were 4 to 12 years old and 50 were 3 years old or younger.
Roughly 100 U.S. soldiers from Charlie Company swept into My Lai on March 16, 1968. They met no enemy fire and saw no Vietnamese males of fighting age. They suffered only one casualty — a GI who shot himself in the foot. All of three enemy weapons were recovered.
Calley ordered his soldiers to aim their M-16 assault rifles into a ditch where dozens of villagers were huddled, pleading for their lives. The only survivors were those shielded from bullets by the layers of bleeding bodies above. Calley fired into the pit, as well as into a group of captured villagers squatting on a trail. He was initially charged with murdering 109 civilians.
When he saw a white-robed Buddhist monk praying over a prostrate elderly woman, he jammed his rifle butt into the monk’s face. After the monk crumpled, insisting he wasn’t Viet Cong, Calley shot him anyway. A little later, he saw a small boy crawl out of the pit. Calley grabbed his arm, tossed him back in, and shot him too. The boy was 2.
In his memoir, Calley said the public’s outrage about slain babies was misplaced.
“On babies everyone’s really hung up,” he wrote. “‘But babies! The little, innocent babies!’ Of course, we’ve been in Vietnam for 10 years now. If we’re in Vietnam another 10, if your son is killed by those babies, you’ll cry at me, ‘Why didn’t you kill those babies that day?’ ”
Seven of Calley’s men refused to follow his orders, but most complied. Ultimately, charges were filed against 25 men, including officers who engineered the subsequent cover-up. The cases against most were dropped. Of the six men tried, only Calley was convicted.
At a 50-year anniversary forum on My Lai, former military judge Gary Solis called it “an epic failure of military justice.”
“I believe the convening authorities just wanted the whole damn My Lai case to go away,” said Solis, a former court-martial prosecutor who taught military law at West Point. “They didn’t want the American public to know the full extent of criminality exhibited by U.S. personnel in My Lai and undermining America’s ongoing war effort.”
Born June 8, 1943, William Laws Calley Jr. was the son of Ruth and William Calley. He grew up with three sisters in Miami, where his father had a construction business.
An indifferent student, Calley was sent to a military school before graduating from a public high school in 1962. He attended Palm Beach Junior College for a year, held a series of odd jobs, and in 1967 enlisted in the Army as the Vietnam War was in full swing.
For decades after his release, Calley managed a Columbus, Ga., jewelry store owned by his wife’s family. He had married Peggy Vick in 1976 at a wedding with 200 guests, including a U.S. district judge who had overturned his conviction but was later overruled. The Calleys’ son, William Laws Calley III, went on to become an electrical engineer.
The Calleys divorced after 30 years and he later moved to Florida.
He broke his silence with a public apology in 2009.
At a friend’s invitation, he spoke at a Kiwanis Club of Greater Columbus lunch: “There is not a day that goes by when I do not feel remorse for
what happened that day in My Lai,” he said, his voice breaking. “I feel remorse for the Vietnamese who were killed, for their families, and for the American soldiers involved and their families. I am very sorry.”
Asked whether following an unlawful order is itself unlawful, Calley said he believed it was, according to an account in the Columbus Ledger-Enquirer.
“If you are asking why I did not stand up to them when I was given the orders, I will have to say that I was a second lieutenant getting orders from my commander and I followed them — foolishly, I guess,” he said.
At his court-martial, Calley’s attorney echoed the defense of top Nazis at their trials in Nuremberg following World War II: He was only following orders.
The day before the attack, Capt. Ernest Medina had gathered the troops of Charlie Company, which he commanded. Most of the men were still relative newcomers to Vietnam, but 20 soldiers — about 10% of the company — had been wounded or killed by buried landmines. Just days before the attack, a popular sergeant had been blown apart by a booby trap that took another soldier’s arms and legs and blinded a third.
Weeks earlier, Calley and others had been kept awake by the sound of screams. At dawn, they discovered the body of a U.S. soldier hoisted on a pole. He had been skinned alive.
Medina told his troops that the next morning they’d be storming My Lai, where intelligence officials had located several hundred members of the crack Viet Cong 48th Local Force Battalion. Because the attack would be on market day, he said, the village would be empty, except for the VC fighters holed up there.
“Our job is to go in rapidly, and to neutralize everything,” Medina told his troops. “To kill everything.”
Asked whether he meant women and children too, Medina, a tough career officer known to his men as “Mad Dog,” was blunt, Calley recounted.
“I mean everything,” he said.
Calley’s account was both supported and disputed by other witnesses. Medina denied it and was acquitted after jurors deliberated for 58 minutes.
Still, Calley said he believed he and his men were under orders to kill anyone they saw as a threat — and women and children had been known to plant landmines, set booby traps and hide Viet Cong fighters. Calley also said he was under pressure from his commander, who told him in angry radio transmissions to “waste” the villagers if they got in the way. The action was to be the first to rout the Viet Cong in My Lai and nearby villages.
“After Medina blasted him for threatening the mission, Calley made the most momentous decision of his life,” wrote historian Howard Jones in “My Lai: Vietnam, 1968, and the Descent into Darkness,” his 2017 account of the massacre. “Since it was impossible to distinguish between friend and foe, the only conclusion was to presume that all Vietnamese were Viet Cong and kill them all.”
Chawkins is a former Times staff writer.
That phrase – “Baby Killer” – became additional ammunition in political confrontations about the Viet Nam War. But Lt. Calley labelled himself, in his own words, by his own admission. Jane Fonda? She’s still alive at 85, but that observation alone shouldn’t have any bearing on the topic.
There should be a consensus today about wasting $1 Trillion or more and sacrificing 59,000 Americans and 2 million Asians – countless more wounded, based on the facts, based on the history, based on all the circumstances, and the simple truth that nineteen years of war (1954-1975) yielded nothing but the same outcome if Johnson had not followed the Joint Chiefs in expanding the war during the mid- ‘60s. LBJ might instead have simply followed the dictates of JFK’s NSAM (National Security Action Memorandum) #263. But you will still find people insisting that it wasn’t a mistake, perhaps owing to a general public misunderstanding of George Kennan’s white-paper written for the JCS during the late 1940s. The general public, after all, had never heard of George Kennan nor ever read his strategic doctrine.
Just by asking those particular people questions to assess their knowledge – for instance, “who created the Saigon Military Mission in 1952?” or “Who became the manufactured constituency for Ngo Dinh Diem?” – you can quickly conclude which opinion is grounded in the greatest ignorance or conversely – accumulated understanding.
It deserves emphasis that concluding a mistake has nothing to do with the honor deserved by most of our men who served. But the naysayers never fail to interject dishonor to our troops as synonymous with the growing conclusion about the war.
What is also very interesting is a prediction made by the famous Longshoreman turned college professor – Eric Hoffer, author of the book “True Believer”. He argued that pulling out of Viet Nam, even as late and delayed the decision to do so, was also a mistake, suggesting that the reversal would eventually lead to an era of shifting public opinion and ascendant fascism generations later.
Decide yourselves whether or not his prediction came true, or that it somehow negates the appropriate choice in face of the original mistake. Just as troubling, “True Believer” describes a phenomenon of today’s politics parallel to the prediction about public opinion. Personally, I’m done with it, inasmuch as old friends no longer suffer so much from their PTSD – waking at 3AM with nightmares, shrieking in puddles of sweat. But make no mistake: whether drafted or draft-dodger, student-deferred or willfully-enlisted, gung-ho or conscientious objector, man or woman – the war had an indelible effect on all of us who had come of age in the mid-1960s – and perhaps many, many more, even if they had yet to be born.
WILLIAM CALLEY, 1943 – 2024 [LA TIMES, 8-1-2024]
Soldier convicted in My Lai massacre in Vietnam
‘I AM VERY SORRY’. Lt. William Calley said he was just following orders to kill everyone but years later expressed remorse. (Joe Holloway, Jr. Associated Press)
By Steve Chawkins
The night before 2nd Lt. William Calley shipped out of Hawaii to Vietnam, he was obliged to read his unit a list of rules regarding their behavior in a new land.
The men were arrayed in a horseshoe around the 5-foot-3, boyish-looking officer as he recited the do’s and don’ts from the Pentagon publication “Vietnam, Our Host.” In his 1971 memoir, he remembered items such as “Do not insult the women … do not assault the women. And — I’m too foggy about it. Items like ‘Be polite.’ ”
“I had only three minutes for Vietnam, Our Host,” he wrote. “I did a very, very poor job.”
Three-and-a-half months later, 24-year-old “Rusty” Calley was at the center of the My Lai massacre, one of the darkest chapters in U.S. military history. In a hamlet that reputedly had been a Viet Cong stronghold, Calley and the men he commanded shot, stabbed, raped, and hurled hand grenades at hundreds of residents later deemed to be unarmed civilians — mostly women, children and elderly men.
Calley, who was convicted of murder in a 1971 court-martial that was widely seen as a trial of the Vietnam War itself, died on April 28, according to his Florida death record, which said he had been living in an apartment in Gainesville. He was 80.
After My Lai, Calley was sentenced to life at hard labor. However, owing to the intervention of President Nixon, he served only a few months in prison before being released to house arrest. During three years of appeals, he lived in a bachelor-quarters apartment at Ft. Benning, Ga.
Military authorities and then-Secretary of the Army Howard Callaway reduced his sentence to 20 years, and then 10. In 1974, he was paroled.
By then, Calley had gained millions of supporters. The White House was flooded with more than 300,000 letters and telegrams denouncing his life sentence. A Gallup poll indicated that 79% of Americans believed he had been made a scapegoat.
After his conviction, a popular song based on “The Battle Hymn of The Republic” — “The Battle Hymn of Lt. Calley” — sold more than a million records : “My name is William Calley / I’m a soldier of this land / I’ve tried to do my duty and to gain the upper hand / But they’ve made me out a villain / They have stamped me with a brand / As we go marching on …”
Even some leaders of the antiwar movement thought Calley had been treated unfairly. “It’s too bad that one man is being made to pay for the brutality of the whole war,” said Dr. Benjamin Spock , the late activist and pediatrician whose books were child-raising bibles for frazzled American parents.
In his memoir, Calley portrayed himself as an easy target for officials trying to sanitize the unpopular war. Once the story of My Lai emerged, “the American government couldn’t say, ‘Oh, that’s how it is in Vietnam, everyone,’ ” He wrote. “It had to protect two million veterans and 200 million Americans. It had to tell everyone, ‘A mad killer did it.’ ”
On March 16, 1968, Calley led one of the three platoons of Charlie Company into the village known by U.S. military planners as My Lai 4. Four hours after their arrival, most of the villagers were dead. At least nine girls and women had been raped and mutilated. “Zippo squads, using their cigarette lighters to ignite thatched rooves, burned down 246 homes. Bodies were dumped down wells. Even the livestock was shot.
At the My Lai museum outside Da Nang in Vietnam — formally known as the Son My War Remnant Site — a marble plaque lists 504 victims by name. Of the 273 women killed, 17 were pregnant. One hundred and sixty victims were 4 to 12 years old and 50 were 3 years old or younger.
Roughly 100 U.S. soldiers from Charlie Company swept into My Lai on March 16, 1968. They met no enemy fire and saw no Vietnamese males of fighting age. They suffered only one casualty — a GI who shot himself in the foot. All of three enemy weapons were recovered.
Calley ordered his soldiers to aim their M-16 assault rifles into a ditch where dozens of villagers were huddled, pleading for their lives. The only survivors were those shielded from bullets by the layers of bleeding bodies above. Calley fired into the pit, as well as into a group of captured villagers squatting on a trail. He was initially charged with murdering 109 civilians.
When he saw a white-robed Buddhist monk praying over a prostrate elderly woman, he jammed his rifle butt into the monk’s face. After the monk crumpled, insisting he wasn’t Viet Cong, Calley shot him anyway. A little later, he saw a small boy crawl out of the pit. Calley grabbed his arm, tossed him back in, and shot him too. The boy was 2.
In his memoir, Calley said the public’s outrage about slain babies was misplaced.
“On babies everyone’s really hung up,” he wrote. “‘But babies! The little, innocent babies!’ Of course, we’ve been in Vietnam for 10 years now. If we’re in Vietnam another 10, if your son is killed by those babies, you’ll cry at me, ‘Why didn’t you kill those babies that day?’ ”
Seven of Calley’s men refused to follow his orders, but most complied. Ultimately, charges were filed against 25 men, including officers who engineered the subsequent cover-up. The cases against most were dropped. Of the six men tried, only Calley was convicted.
At a 50-year anniversary forum on My Lai, former military judge Gary Solis called it “an epic failure of military justice.”
“I believe the convening authorities just wanted the whole damn My Lai case to go away,” said Solis, a former court-martial prosecutor who taught military law at West Point. “They didn’t want the American public to know the full extent of criminality exhibited by U.S. personnel in My Lai and undermining America’s ongoing war effort.”
Born June 8, 1943, William Laws Calley Jr. was the son of Ruth and William Calley. He grew up with three sisters in Miami, where his father had a construction business.
An indifferent student, Calley was sent to a military school before graduating from a public high school in 1962. He attended Palm Beach Junior College for a year, held a series of odd jobs, and in 1967 enlisted in the Army as the Vietnam War was in full swing.
For decades after his release, Calley managed a Columbus, Ga., jewelry store owned by his wife’s family. He had married Peggy Vick in 1976 at a wedding with 200 guests, including a U.S. district judge who had overturned his conviction but was later overruled. The Calleys’ son, William Laws Calley III, went on to become an electrical engineer.
The Calleys divorced after 30 years and he later moved to Florida.
He broke his silence with a public apology in 2009.
At a friend’s invitation, he spoke at a Kiwanis Club of Greater Columbus lunch: “There is not a day that goes by when I do not feel remorse for
what happened that day in My Lai,” he said, his voice breaking. “I feel remorse for the Vietnamese who were killed, for their families, and for the American soldiers involved and their families. I am very sorry.”
Asked whether following an unlawful order is itself unlawful, Calley said he believed it was, according to an account in the Columbus Ledger-Enquirer.
“If you are asking why I did not stand up to them when I was given the orders, I will have to say that I was a second lieutenant getting orders from my commander and I followed them — foolishly, I guess,” he said.
At his court-martial, Calley’s attorney echoed the defense of top Nazis at their trials in Nuremberg following World War II: He was only following orders.
The day before the attack, Capt. Ernest Medina had gathered the troops of Charlie Company, which he commanded. Most of the men were still relative newcomers to Vietnam, but 20 soldiers — about 10% of the company — had been wounded or killed by buried landmines. Just days before the attack, a popular sergeant had been blown apart by a booby trap that took another soldier’s arms and legs and blinded a third.
Weeks earlier, Calley and others had been kept awake by the sound of screams. At dawn, they discovered the body of a U.S. soldier hoisted on a pole. He had been skinned alive.
Medina told his troops that the next morning they’d be storming My Lai, where intelligence officials had located several hundred members of the crack Viet Cong 48th Local Force Battalion. Because the attack would be on market day, he said, the village would be empty, except for the VC fighters holed up there.
“Our job is to go in rapidly, and to neutralize everything,” Medina told his troops. “To kill everything.”
Asked whether he meant women and children too, Medina, a tough career officer known to his men as “Mad Dog,” was blunt, Calley recounted.
“I mean everything,” he said.
Calley’s account was both supported and disputed by other witnesses. Medina denied it and was acquitted after jurors deliberated for 58 minutes.
Still, Calley said he believed he and his men were under orders to kill anyone they saw as a threat — and women and children had been known to plant landmines, set booby traps and hide Viet Cong fighters. Calley also said he was under pressure from his commander, who told him in angry radio transmissions to “waste” the villagers if they got in the way. The action was to be the first to rout the Viet Cong in My Lai and nearby villages.
“After Medina blasted him for threatening the mission, Calley made the most momentous decision of his life,” wrote historian Howard Jones in “My Lai: Vietnam, 1968, and the Descent into Darkness,” his 2017 account of the massacre. “Since it was impossible to distinguish between friend and foe, the only conclusion was to presume that all Vietnamese were Viet Cong and kill them all.”
Chawkins is a former Times staff writer.
Last edited:
Facebook
Twitter