Rubbing noise when turning wheel
I'd put them side by side and start checking dimensions. Diameter, offset, thickness, etc.
They either sold you one incorrect rotor, or one was packaged and/or labeled incorrectly.
Any rub marks on the "bad" rotor? That would point you in the right direction.
Inside many liberals is a totalitarian screaming to get out. They donít like to have another point of view in the room that they donít quash and the way they try to quash it is by character assassination and name calling. - David Horowitz